The Best Mystery Games for Xbox One

Update 28 November 2023: Forest Grove added at rank #30.

Xbox One Playstation 4 PC Windows Xbox Series X Playstation 5 Nintendo Switch Android

Unravel the mysteries of the universe in Outer Wilds, an award-winning open world game. Explore an ever-evolving solar system, uncover alien secrets, and enjoy a thought-provoking narrative. With no enemies to fight, you're free to discover at your own pace. Get ready for an unforgettable adventure in space!

• Unique and immersive gameplay experience
• Beautiful and intricate world-building
• Thought-provoking narrative
• Encourages fearless discovery
• Captures the mysteries of the universe

• May cause motion sickness
• Game's physics can lead to unexpected deaths

• exploration
• mystery
• puzzle
• open-world
• discovery
• space
• sci-fi
• endless
• first-person
• adventure
• day
• story

Good match + 77 Bad match - 131

IOS iPhone Nintendo Switch Xbox One Playstation 4 PC Windows

In Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective, you're a ghost solving your own murder mystery before sunrise. With time manipulation, object possession, and mind-bending puzzles, you'll uncover a story full of twists and turns. This HD remaster offers an upgraded visual experience, new music arrangements, and a gallery of artwork, making it the ultimate version of this classic adventure.

• Engaging story with satisfying twists
• Endearing, unique characters
• Fantastic art style and graphic upgrades
• Fun voice acting
• Intriguing puzzle-solving mechanics

• Puzzles can be frustrating and require trial-and-error
• Unhelpful hint system
• Lack of bonus content

• puzzle
• mystery
• detective
• cult
• adventure
• narrative
• supernatural
• classic
• assassin

Good match + 20 Bad match

Playstation 5 Xbox One PC Windows Playstation 4 Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch

Unravel the mysteries of The Forgotten City, a time-looping adventure set in an ancient Roman city. Engage with well-crafted characters, navigate ethical dilemmas, and uncover secrets that will keep you hooked. Despite its humble origins as a Skyrim mod, this game offers a captivating experience with multiple endings, making every decision count.

• Gripping story with clever twists
• Immersive, detailed visuals
• Strong voice performances
• Thought-provoking themes and ethical dilemmas
• Multiple dialogue options and quest-solving approaches

• Backtracking can be tedious
• Limited impact of player's chosen backstory
• Occasional slowdowns and glitches
• Fixed map despite vast experience

• mystery
• narrative
• adventure
• rpg
• story
• historical
• exploration
• skyrim
• combat
• crime
• thought-provoking
• discovery
• puzzle
• first-person

Good match + 88 Bad match - 217

l PC Windows Playstation 5 Playstation 4 Xbox Series X Xbox One j

This Bed We Made is a third-person mystery game in which you play as a maid in a 1950s hotel and snoop around strangers' rooms to uncover their deadly secrets. Discover what links guests together in this tale of love, heartbreak and murder!

• mystery
• noir
• detective
• cinematic
• lgbtq
• third-person
• walking-simulator
• investigation
• 1950s
• crime
• fiction
• choices
• historical
• story
• romance

Good match + 2 Bad match

Xbox One Xbox Series X PC Windows

Pentiment can be seen as a educational game set in the 15th century, combining point-and-click adventure with role-playing elements and a branching narrative. It follows Andreas Mahler as he tries to clear his friend's name while uncovering the secrets of a small Bavarian town.

• Captivating story
• Immersive atmosphere
• Beautiful visuals and sound
• Interesting characters and dialogue
• Deep RPG elements and replayability

• Limited number of puzzles which are not particularly challenging

• historical
• narrative
• mystery
• medieval
• choices
• rpg
• book
• crime
• adventure
• detective
• story
• fiction
• stylized
• local
• education

Good match + 25 Bad match - 52

Playstation 4 Xbox One Nintendo Switch PC Windows Android IOS iPhone

Enter the thrilling found-phone mystery of Doctor Who: The Lonely Assassins and uncover the chilling truth before it's too late. Help solve cryptic puzzles and interact with authentic characters as you navigate through an eerie abandoned house. But watch out for the Weeping Angels! Immerse yourself in this unique blend of horror and sci-fi elements that will leave you wanting more.

• Immersive storytelling
• Challenging puzzles
• Impressive graphics and sound design
• Replay value
• Unique blend of horror and sci-fi elements

• Short length compared to other games
• No Steam achievements

• mystery
• horror
• puzzle
• sci-fi
• interactive
• simulacra
• adventure
• narrative
• visual-novel
• immersive
• fiction
• investigation
• detective

Good match + 107 Bad match - 192

Xbox One Mac OS Nintendo Switch PC Windows Xbox Series X

Strange Horticulture is an occult puzzle game in which you play as the proprietor of a local plant store. Find and identify new plants, pet your cat, speak to a coven, or join a cult. Use your collection of powerful plants to influence the story and unravel Undermere’s dark mysteries.

• mystery
• investigation
• puzzle
• nature
• detective
• relaxing
• lovecraftian
• exploration
• multiple-endings
• choices
• 2d
• alternate-universe
• simulation
• clue
• lovecraft

Good match + 32 Bad match - 56

Xbox Series X Nintendo Switch PC Windows Xbox One

Dive into the mysteries of Beacon Pines, a charming yet eerie adventure where you control the fate of the story. As Luka, you'll uncover hidden truths, meet memorable characters, and explore stunning hand-drawn landscapes. With multiple endings to discover, you'll be captivated by this immersive tale filled with surprising twists.

• Intriguing and creative story
• Well-developed, memorable characters
• Multiple endings based on your choices
• Stunning hand-drawn art
• Engaging gameplay mechanics

• The large number of characters can be overwhelming

• choices
• narrative
• visual-novel
• mystery
• cute
• cozy
• adventure
• narration
• exploration
• story
• emotional
• colourful
• interactive
• horror
• conspiracy

Good match + 27 Bad match - 46

Xbox One Mac OS PC Windows

Return of the Obra Dinn is an adventure puzzle game set in a supernatural maritime world. Players assume the role of an appraiser for a maritime insurance company and are given a pocket watch that reveals the fates of the ship's unfortunate passengers. The game features stunning foley work, voice acting, and score to set its tone. Players must use their deductive reasoning to unravel what happened to all passengers on board.

• Mystery elements require sound deductive reasoning
• Brilliant foley work and voice acting
• Innovative visuals inspired by early computer games
• Supernatural angle adds intrigue and suspense
• High replay value

• Simulated assistance may make some tasks too easy
• Minimalist aesthetic can be off-putting to some players
• Limited area surrounding each scene restricts exploration

• detective
• mystery
• puzzle

Good match + 42 Bad match - 66

Android Linux Mac OS PC Windows Xbox One

Firewatch is a single-player first-person mystery set in the Wyoming wilderness, where your only emotional lifeline is the person on the other end of a handheld radio.

• mystery
• walking-simulator
• narrative
• first-person
• exploration
• story
• park
• adventure
• boss
• thriller

Good match + 49 Bad match - 88

Not seeing your game? Click here to add it!

Thanks a lot for your contribution.

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7dnzGmqSeq5yeuKZ6wqikaJqVqMFus8CmnKxlkq56tcXPnmamsaOpsrPFjrGZqLCfo7I%3D